Narrowly missing out on the top slot is this episode which revolves around the theme... 3. She gives him an ultimatum: her or his suits. Marshall makes an appointment with Stella and finds out that she does like Ted. Lily’s ex-boyfriend shows up in an effort to win her back, a groomsman tackles the photographer, and the harp player is in labor. The thankful band members help Marshall surprise Lily at the airport by playing “Auld Lang Syne.” It’s a very romantic moment that shows that some traditions should always be kept. As Robin contemplates moving in with her new boyfriend Don, Ted and Barney both decide that they want her back. Marshall warns Barney that the third slap in their "slap bet" will be coming on Thanksgiving night. While we don’t learn who the Mother (Cristin Milioti) is until the final season, we get to watch the many entertaining escapades of Ted and his friends over the course of nine years. | The holiday episode is a classic television trope most often used to celebrate the likes of Christmas, Halloween, or Thanksgiving. | They can have the small outdoor wedding they had initially wanted before going through with the big disastrous ceremony. A real emotional rollercoaster. Right away you begin to identify with characters and become invested in Ted's story and how everyone else will play into it. Meanwhile, Ted and Robin are still dealing with the aftermath of their breakup. The truth eventually comes out when Barney uncovers a video from Robin’s past. Meanwhile, Ted finds out Robin is a drinking game for his architecture students. It’s actually the gloriously cheesy music video for the song “Let’s Go to the Mall,” from Robin’s days as a teen pop star in Canada. What's your favorite How I Met Your Mother episode? He also discovers that he has a sprained ankle and his coat is burnt. When the bartender returns, they move the party back to their apartment. Alone at the Farhampton Inn, she sings a beautiful version of “Le Vie En Rose,” (showing off Milioti’s amazing voice) which Ted overhears. At the Architect's Ball, Ted runs into Victoria, who tells him that she's getting married. Other episodes that almost made the list include "How Your Mother Met Me," "The Naked Man," "Trilogy Time," "Swarley" and "How Lily Stole Christmas." 30 min Comedy, Romance. Meanwhile, Marshall and Lily have big plans for a rare night out. Her boyfriend proposes to her while she’s in Farhampton to play in the band at Barney and Robin’s wedding. Arrivederci, Fiero (Season 2, Episode 17): The gang reminisces about their adventures in Marshall's old Pontiac Fiero. Stars: Best How I Met Your Mother Episodes 12. Meanwhile, Ted and Robin sleep together on the night before Thanksgiving. Meanwhile, Marshall and Lily think they've revolutionized modern marriage when they begin sleeping in separate beds. | Marshall thinks she is married, and Barney thinks she was a porn star. He doles out the first slap right away, and saves the others for future episodes. | They make a bet that whoever is right gets to slap the other. We can't hear "I'm Gonna Be (500 Miles)" without thinking of this episode. Director: TV-14 Ted asks his friends what happened and finds out his wild night included falling off a table while singing karaoke, being set on fire by Barney (Neil Patrick Harris), and drunk dialing Robin (Cobie Smulders) multiple times. Lily obviously has a problem with it too, as she interrupts his date to stop him from kissing another woman. With Barney reeling in pain, the gang gathers around the piano while Marshall plays a song he wrote for the event, titled “You Just Got Slapped.” Best Slapsgiving ever. These are the show's most legendary episodes. Ted tries to keep his irresponsible sister from hooking up with Barney during her trip to New York, and Robin starts hanging out with Marshall at a bar for Minnesotans, not telling them that she's really Canadian. Josh Radnor, When he does decide to listen, he is disappointed to hear that it’s a pocket dial, and gives an impassioned speech to his friends about how unfair it is that his dad is gone. The simple, intimate wedding is much more fitting for the couple. How I Met Your Mother makes full use of this trope during its nine seasons.